My home and garage were victim to the flood also, but we were much more fortunate than our neighbors, whose homes were totally destroyed. Those of us who work with insurance take much knowledge for granted. But, many people have had a tough time finding information, and have had to act without direction from anyone just to
Parks Chastain
Cowpokes and Deductibles
I recently resolved a case that I thought was interesting for this day and age, particularly here in Tennessee. Here’s the scenario – an insured claims to have had cattle stolen from him on multiple occasions, but by the same person – yes, you guessed it, the “cowpoke” in our story.
It seems that our “cowpoke&rdquo…
THE “CO-INSURANCE” PENALTY – OR INSUFFICIENT INSURANCE TO VALUE – AND ITS IMPACT ON AN INSURED
coinsurance “co-insurance” “insurance to value” formula…
Continue Reading THE “CO-INSURANCE” PENALTY – OR INSUFFICIENT INSURANCE TO VALUE – AND ITS IMPACT ON AN INSURED
In Order to Invoke Replacement Cost Coverage, Does An Insured Have to Rebuild at the Same Location?
In most cases, the answer is no. Most policies use replacement cost at a specific location as a measure of the maximum recovery that can be afforded under a property insurance policy. Most policies contain a “Valuation” condition similar to the following:
B. Replacement Cost – When replacement cost is shown on the “declarations” for covered property, …
The Little Recognized Side Effect of the Broad Duty to Defend
duty defend indemnify “duty to defend” broad…
Continue Reading The Little Recognized Side Effect of the Broad Duty to Defend
THIRD-PARTY COVERAGE LITIGATION ISSUES NOW ADDRESSED ON BLOG
Although the focus of this blog was, and will remain, first-party insurance coverage litigation, many of our readers have asked if we are going to include third-party coverage litigation topics in the blog. While we initially wanted to remain “purists,” so to speak, demand is such that we will create a separate “Category” entitled “Third-Party …
Mediating First Party Property Cases
In the past two weeks, I have mediated three first party property cases. None of them was alike, and I wanted to share some thoughts on approaching such mediations from the carrier’s perspective, and some comments on the way the insureds have approached the mediation – making it better or worse for fruitful negotiations.
…
Policyholder’s Advocate’s Blog Questioning Misconceptions on Advances Shows Extent of Misconceptions, and the Reasons Why They Are Problematic
William F. "Chip" Merlin, Jr., of the Merlin Law Group, wrote a blog in which he derided (a nice word) the blog I posted on August 18, entitled “Advances-Common Misconception.” Mr. Merlin is a Plaintiff’s/Policyholder’s Attorney. (www.merlinlawgroup.com). His website describes him as “The Policyholder’s Advocate.” His advocacy is evident as his …
Advances – Common Misconceptions
I want to address some misconceptions about advances under first party policies. By this, I mean a request for money made by an insured before the investigation is complete. While the circumstances of an insured’s loss often place the insured in a difficult financial situation, that situation does not alter the insurance contract. Therefore, let’s debunk some…
Tennessee Court Of Appeals Rules That Submission To Examination Under Oath Is Condition Precedent To Recovery
I commend to your reading the recent case of Spears v. Tennessee Farmers Mutual Insurance Company, No. M2008-00842-COA-R3-CV (Tenn. Ct. App. Middle Section), filed July 17, 2009. For a PDF copy of this case, download here (pdf). In this case, the Court was presented with the question of whether the failure of an insured to …