So you finally got a case in which you’re just certain the insurance company is acting in bad faith . . . What do you do now? Protect it! In a case where you think you’ve caught the insurance company red-handed for acting in bad faith, it is crucial that you take the steps to
May 2009
Misrepresentation on Application Concerning Ownership of Property Voids Policy
On April 30, 2009, the Tennessee Court of Appeals issued yet another opinion on the topic of misrepresentations on insurance applications. The case is Tennessee Farmers Mut. Ins. Co. v. Farrar (view slip opinion here).
First, it should be noted that T.C.A. 56-7-103 provides that a misrepresentation on an application voids the policy if…
The Importance of a Diary
Policyholders all too often underestimate the importance of keeping a diary of the various events that occur during the course of a claim. Why is it important? First, it is a simple fact that memories fade with time. Although claims should be resolved promptly, they often are not. The process can be complicated with numerous…
Top 10 Reasons Complaints are Made Against Insurance Companies
According to an April 28, 2009 report by the National Association of Insurance Commissioners ("NAIC"), the top ten reasons consumers complain about their insurance coverage are as follows:
- Claim Handling – Delays
- Claim Handling – Denial of Claim
- Claim Handling – Unsatisfactory Settlement/Offer
- Claim Handling – Other
- Underwriting – Premium & Rating
- Underwriting – Cancellation
- Policyholder
…
The Valued Policy Statute Should Not Be Limited to Losses Caused by Fire
Parks Chastain recently authored a post here in which he opined that Tennessee’s valued policy statute should apply only to losses caused by fire, not wind. I disagree.
Tennessee’s valued policy statutes (T.C.A. 56-7-801 through 803) were enacted in 1927, and last edited just a few years later. Read together, these statutory provisions, known as the…
Litigation Tactics – The Coverage Lawyer Need Not Be A Witness, Even in Bad Faith Cases
Many times, lawyers for insureds attempt to make an insurance company’s pre-litigation coverage counsel a witness. I have faced two arguments on this issue. I have been a witness in a couple of cases, and must say that I do prefer the role of attorney. But, I think it is useful to debunk the two…
“But the agent…” – Ending the Litigation Tactic of Blaming the Agent
In litigating coverage cases on behalf of insurance carriers, I often hear – “But, my agent said…” or “But, I told the agent that…” In Tennessee, juries still hold litigants to a degree of personal accountability and responsibility, particularly when they have had the opportunity to read the document about which they may be claiming…
The Meaning of “Total Loss” Under Tennessee’s Valued Policy Law
Often, litigants attempt to use the Valued Policy Law to establish that losses are total for purposes of maximizing policy recovery. In many instances, unless the home or structure is totally destroyed and “on the ground,” so to speak, expert proof can be adduced to establish that much of the building could be re-used, and…
Tennessee’s Valued Policy Law Should Apply Only To Losses By Fire, Not Windstorm
For the past two years, the spring months have brought severe and deadly tornados to various parts of Tennessee. One issue that has often arisen, but has not yet been addressed by any Tennessee appellate court, is the extent to which Tennessee’s “Valued Policy Law” would, or should, apply to wind or tornado losses.
Tennessee’s…
An Outline for Dealing with the Judicial Estoppel Defense
Insurers often assert the doctrine of judicial estoppel as a defense to first party claims when the insured filed bankrupcty within a few years prior to an insured loss. The most common scenario is a homeowner files bankruptcy, and utilizes the amount exempted by bankruptcy law as the value of his or her personal property…